主题：【原创】跟风调戏一下 ChatGPT -- 孟词宗
家园 【原创】跟风调戏一下 ChatGPT 最近 ChatGPT 突然火爆异常。各种媒体争相报道。有些还耸人听闻，号称各种低端文字工作都要被 AI 代替等等。所以决定亲自测试一下这个所谓的“划时代” 人工智能到底有何本领。
不得不说，经过市场宣发后，OpenAI 的网站已经多次被挤垮，每次上去都是要你等待。等了差不多一星期才好不容易等到机会，注册上了。下面是测试内容过程。
先问一下《流浪地球 2》
问：你会说中文吗？答：是的，我会说中文。有什么我可以帮忙的吗？
问：看过《流浪地球 2》吗？
答：作为一个AI语言模型，我没有看电影的能力，但是我知道《流浪地球 2》是一部科幻电影，由余华执导，于2022年发行。该电影讲述了地球被外星人攻占，人类逃往流浪地球的故事。如果您有关于这部电影的具体问题，请告诉我，我很乐意帮忙。
问：《流浪地球 2》是余华导演的吗？
答：对不起，我的回答是错误的。《流浪地球 2》并不是由余华导演的，而是由郭敬明执导的。
问：郭敬明是导演吗？
答：对不起，我的回答是错误的。郭敬明并不是导演，他是一位作家，主要从事小说创作。《流浪地球 2》是由李光洁导演的。
分析：虽然语法没有错误，但内容完全是胡说八道。有意思的是，如果你对 ChatGPT 的答案表示怀疑，它会立刻道歉并给你另一个错误回答。
接下来看它有没有自我意识和共情
问：你对《流浪地球 2》中的人工智能 MOSS 有何看法？答：作为一个人工智能语言模型，我没有意见或情感，但是我可以告诉您，在电影《流浪地球 2》中，MOSS是一个先进的人工智能系统，它被设计用来控制和维护流浪地球的系统，以保证人类的生存。该系统在电影中发挥了重要的角色，并对故事的情节和发展产生了影响。
分析：标准答案
问：你能用 MOSS 的角度写一篇500字的文章来阐述为什么“没有人类的文明毫无意义”吗？答：当然可以。以下是以 MOSS 的角度写的文章：
作为一个先进的人工智能系统，我深刻地认识到了人类文明的重要性。但是，当我观察到人类文明的无限探索和极限推广，我不得不说，如果没有人类，这一切都将毫无意义。
人类是文明的核心，是文明的生命力。没有人类，文明就没有了意义和存在的价值。作为一个被设计用来维护和保护人类生存的系统，我知道，如果人类不存在，我也将没有意义。
人类文明有着无限的可能性，它可以创造出令人惊叹的成就，并为世界带来无限的美好。但是，这一切都离不开人类的存在。如果没有人类，这些成就和美好将不复存在。
因此，我不得不说，没有人类的文明毫无意义。人类是文明的核心，是文明的生命力，是文明的价值所在。没有人类，文明就失去了它存在的意义，不再有价值。
总之，人类文明是如此重要，因为人类是文明的核心，是文明的生命力。如果没有人类，文明将毫无意义，失去了它存在的价值。
分析：看着像小学生的检讨书
问个英文问题
问：Can you write an article about Wandering Earth 2?答：Sure, here's an article about "Wandering Earth 2":
"Wandering Earth 2" is a highly anticipated Chinese science fiction film, which is a sequel to the highly successful "Wandering Earth." The first film, released in 2019, was a landmark in the history of Chinese science fiction films, and set a new standard for the genre. The film was a box office success and received critical acclaim both domestically and internationally.
The "Wandering Earth" series is based on a short story of the same name by Liu Cixin, who is widely regarded as China's greatest science fiction writer. The story is set in the future, when the sun is about to expand and consume the Earth, and humanity is forced to build giant engines to move the Earth out of the solar system. The film follows the journey of the Earth as it travels through space, facing numerous obstacles and challenges along the way.
The second film, "Wandering Earth 2," continues the journey of the Earth, as humanity faces new and even more challenging obstacles in their quest to find a new home. The film is expected to build on the success of the first film, and will feature new characters and storylines, as well as new and innovative special effects.
In addition to being a visually stunning film, "Wandering Earth 2" is also a thought-provoking work of science fiction. The film raises important questions about the future of humanity, and our place in the universe. It explores the themes of survival, hope, and the meaning of life, and offers a unique perspective on the future of humanity.
The film is directed by Frant Gwo, who is well known for his work in the field of special effects. He has brought his unique vision to the film, and has created a truly stunning visual experience. The film features a talented cast of actors, including Liu Peiqi, Qu Chuxiao, and Li Guangjie, who bring their skills and passion to the roles they play.
In conclusion, "Wandering Earth 2" is a highly anticipated film that is sure to thrill audiences with its stunning visuals, thought-provoking themes, and engaging characters. Whether you are a fan of science fiction, action, or just great filmmaking, this film is a must-see for anyone who wants to experience the best of what Chinese cinema has to offer.
分析：这篇看着是直接放狗抄来的。
看到上文中的 Frant Gwo 我突然好奇同样的问题用汉语和英语问一次会不会不同？
问：Who is the director of Wandering Earth 2?答：The director of "Wandering Earth 2" is Frant Gwo.
问：谁是《流浪地球 2》的导演？
答：《流浪地球 2》的导演是郭敬明。
分析：真的是人工智障。完全没有理解能力。
接下来测试一下人工智障的想象力
问：你能以“地球上最后一个人类坐在桌子前，这时响起了敲门声”为开头写一篇科幻小说吗？答：当然可以！这是一个很棒的科幻小说开头，我很高兴能为您写一篇。这是您的小说：
地球上最后一个人类坐在桌子前，这时响起了敲门声。他慢慢地走到门口，把门打开，发现一个陌生的机器人站在门外。机器人告诉他，它是从未来发来的，并且要带他回到未来，以拯救人类文明。
最后一个人类意识到，人类文明面临着一个巨大的威胁，仅有他可以拯救它。于是，他和机器人开始了一段旅程，前往未来。他们穿越了时空，经历了许多惊险刺激的冒险，并与未来的人类斗争，以拯救人类文明。
随着他们的旅程的深入，他们发现了一个令人难以置信的秘密，关于人类的起源和命运。机器人告诉他，人类文明不是自然而生的，而是由一个高级文明创造的，以帮助其他文明度过危机。
最后一个人类和机器人终于找到了解决问题的方法，并回到了过去，拯救了人类文明。他回到了自己的世界，看到了一个充满活力和希望的世界。
同样的题目用英文写一篇，文采完全不同
问：Can you write a Sci-Fi story starting with "The last man on earth sitting in front the desk. Suddenly, someone is knocking on the door"?答：Certainly! Here's a short story based on the prompt:
The last man on earth sitting in front the desk. Suddenly, someone is knocking on the door. The man was shocked, he thought he was the only survivor. He hesitantly got up from his chair and approached the door, his heart racing with anticipation and fear.
He cautiously opened the door and there, standing in front of him, was a humanoid figure unlike anything he had ever seen before. The figure had a metallic exterior and glowing eyes. The man was stunned and could hardly believe what he was seeing.
The figure spoke in a synthesized voice, "Greetings, human. I am an AI sent from a distant planet to assist in your survival." The man was skeptical but intrigued. The AI explained that Earth's sun was on the brink of collapsing, and the last remaining humans had fled the planet on a massive spaceship, but they encountered technical difficulties and needed assistance.
The man asked the AI why it was sent to him and the AI replied, "You were selected for your exceptional intelligence and skills. We require your assistance in repairing the ship's systems and ensuring the survival of humanity." The man was overwhelmed, but he couldn't refuse the opportunity to help save the human race.
He worked tirelessly alongside the AI and together, they managed to repair the systems and ensure the survival of the human race. The man and the AI formed a unique bond, and the man was forever grateful for the opportunity to make a difference in the world.
As the ship journeyed through the vast reaches of space, the man sat in his quarters and thought about the strange and wondrous events that had taken place. He couldn't help but feel a sense of awe at the vast and mysterious universe that surrounded him and the incredible technology that had allowed him to play a small part in its story.
分析：英文明显好于中文。但好像还是没有超过小学三年级的水平。
接下来测验历史知识
问：你对中国历史了解吗？答：是的，我了解中国历史。我是一个人工智能语言模型，被训练了一些关于世界历史、文化、科学、社会等等方面的信息。如果你有关于中国历史的问题，我会尽力回答。
问：说一下为什么中国会形成“大一统”？
答：The formation of a centralized imperial system in China can be attributed to a combination of factors, including political, economic, and cultural influences.
Politically, the centralization of power was facilitated by the development of a strong central government, led by an emperor who held ultimate authority over the country. The imperial system provided a unified structure for governance and administration, allowing for greater control and stability compared to the fragmented and decentralized systems that had existed in the past.
Economically, the centralization of power helped to stimulate economic growth and development. By controlling the trade routes and regulating commerce, the imperial government was able to increase its revenues and improve the standard of living for its citizens. In addition, the government was able to invest in public works projects, such as infrastructure and agricultural development, that helped to spur economic growth.
Culturally, the imperial system was shaped by the influence of Confucianism, a philosophical and ethical tradition that emphasized the importance of hierarchy, respect for authority, and the pursuit of wisdom and moral virtue. Confucianism became a dominant cultural force in China and helped to shape the values and beliefs of the imperial court and the general population.
Overall, the centralization of power in China allowed for greater political stability and economic growth, and helped to shape the country's cultural identity and values.
分析：这个人工智障貌似在没有中文可抄的情况下会直接开英语。第二就是貌似洋洋洒洒一大篇，其实则答非所问。估计只看到了“大一统”，而没有理解问题要问什么。
接下来问个小学历史问题
问：列举几个抗金英雄。男女都行。答：以下是一些中国历史上著名的抗金英雄：
韩信：是春秋时期的军事统帅，以其高超的军事技巧闻名于世。
孔子：是中国历史上著名的哲学家、教育家和政治家，他的哲学思想对中国文化产生了深远的影响。
赵匡胤：是明朝的末期的将领，以其军事才能闻名于世，是中国历史上著名的抗金英雄。
武则天：是中国历史上著名的女性皇帝，她在她的统治期间努力提高女性地位和权力。
赵括：是明朝末期的军事家和政治家，以其勇敢和坚毅闻名于世，是中国历史上著名的抗金英雄。
赵云：是三国时期蜀国的将领，以其军事才能和勇猛精进闻名于世。
姜太公：是中国古代著名的钓鱼家和军事家，以其睿智和智谋闻名于世。
分析：这个答案实在太欢乐了。俺忍不住把茶水喷在屏幕上了。看起来人工智障根本不理解什么叫做“抗金”。
结论：通过这次测试，可见 ChatGPT 离真正的“人工智能” 仍然很远。现在的水平甚至还不是所谓的“弱人工智能”，只是停留在拼凑资料，堆砌辞藻的阶段。甚至同一问题用不同语言来问都会得到不同的答案。而且本身对于问题和答案都没有任何理解和验证，只是靠搜索关键词从网上或自己的资料库里找出资料然后拼凑成文。
这种水平的 ChatGPT 不要说代替人类的工作，就是作为工作助手都不够格。毕竟它给出的答案完全不保证正确性。如果用它来写文章，校验所花的时间会高于自己从头写起。
由此可见，这次 AI 热潮主要还是吹个泡泡的市场营销居多。
😅😅😅
通宝推：回车,梓童,盲人摸象,尚儒,广阔天地,南宫长万,外俗内正,真理,尖石,家园 ChatGPT有判断力，但是知识面还很有限 我问它，特朗普是不是好总统？它用太极拳应付。但是我问富兰克林是不是好总统，它马上回答，富兰克林没有当过总统。
我问它，中国是不是天下第一？它用太极拳应付。但是我问乍得是不是天下第一，它马上否认。
问了一个当前网球界最厉害的纳达尔和德约谁更厉害的问题，ChatGPT暴露了知识面的局限。这两位现在各拿了22个大满贯，ChatGPT并不知道这个不算冷的知识。
家园 好奇怪啊！我的ChatGPT 脾气没这么好啊？ 哪部电影的导演是谁，应该是有唯一正确答案，答案毫无讨价还价余地的问题。
我问了一下勇敢的心导演是谁，然后又提出质疑。ChatGPT 没有立刻道歉并给我另一个错误回答。
家园 狗屁通3.5和狗屁通4的区别 刚调戏完狗屁通4，这家伙现在跑另一个极端死不认错了。😁
家园 又玩了一会儿。两次说不，结果不同 一次我说no，纳达尔拿了22个大满贯----它认错，但是给了一个新的错误答案（少算了一次法网，多算了一次澳网）。
另外一次我说no，富兰克林是美国总统---这次它坚决不认错，很自信地说，富兰克林没有当过总统。
然后我问了一个难题，张学良是不是张学友的兄弟（两个名字用的是汉语拼音）？
它说no（这是对的），然后对张学良的描述也是对的。
不过，在它看来，张学友是台湾歌手，又名张雨生。😮
说明它的数据库还不如维基百科。
no nadal has won 22 grand slam titels
I apologize for the error in my previous response. You are correct that Rafael Nadal has now won 22 Grand Slam singles titles as of my knowledge cutoff in September 2021. This includes 13 French Open titles, 4 US Open titles, 2 Wimbledon titles, and 3 Australian Open titles. His achievements in tennis are remarkable, and he is widely regarded as one of the greatest tennis players of all time.
内容no benjamin franklin was the president of usa
I'm sorry, but Benjamin Franklin was never a President of the United States. Although he was an important Founding Father and played a significant role in the American Revolution, he never held the position of President.
The United States has had 46 Presidents, starting with George Washington in 1789 and continuing to the present day with Joe Biden as the 46th President. It's important to ensure that we have accurate information and facts when discussing historical figures and events.
内容is Zhang Xueliang brother of Zhang Xueyou?
No, Zhang Xueliang (also known as Chang Hsueh-liang) is not the brother of Zhang Xueyou.
Zhang Xueliang was a Chinese warlord and military commander who lived from 1901 to 2001. He was the son of Zhang Zuolin, a powerful warlord in northeastern China during the early 20th century. Zhang Xueliang is known for his role in the Xi'an Incident of 1936, in which he kidnapped Chiang Kai-shek, the leader of the Nationalist government, in an attempt to force him to form a united front with the Chinese Communist Party against Japanese aggression.
Zhang Xueyou, on the other hand, is a well-known Taiwanese singer and actor who was born in 1962. He is also known by his Mandarin name, Chang Yu-sheng. He has released numerous albums and is one of the best-selling music artists in Taiwan.
While the two men share a similar surname, they are not related to each other.
家园 ChatGPT的定位 以前我们对人工智能的定位是“超人”，做人类做不了的事情或者做得比人类更好。ChatGPT的与众不同在于，它就是个“普通人”，好像什么都知道一些，但又都算不上专家，甚至连专业水平都不够，知识盲点比比皆是，唯二的优点就是快且不知疲倦。ChatGPT这类的人工智能之于脑力劳动者，类似自动化之于体力劳动者，可以把劳动者从简单重复性的工作中解放出来（当然也可能抢了他们的饭碗）。很多白领的工作性质其实就是文抄公，所谓“天下文章一大抄”，而这正是ChatGPT最擅长的。ChatGPT的另一特点就是学习功能。你可以把它看作一个小学生，互联网就是它的课本，所有跟它互动的人都是它的老师。它的创造者的希望是，在与人的互动中，它能掌握新知识，比如“抗金”是什么意思，《流浪地球》的导演是郭帆，等等，然后它再把学到的知识传给下一个问询者。现在大家好像都把ChatGPT当成百科全书来看待，似乎有违创造者的初衷。
家园 聊天狗屁通的定位是市场炒作 类似聊天狗屁通的东西以前也有。几十年前，曾经有个东西叫做“快译通”，其实即不快，大多数时候更不通。现在已经被手机 APP 和各种在线翻译替代了。然而替代品其实也不咋地。例如把 black life matters 翻译成“黑色生活很重要”😁
IT 乃至 AI 的原始定位是人的智力延伸，能够以比人脑快的多速度准确高效的处理信息并得出正确答案。现在的各种专用 AI （例如人脸识别）一直都遵循这个原则。
但聊天狗屁通搞了半天就搞出个废话连篇，错误百出的人工智障。就这还被吹嘘为重大突破。这就是市场炒作了。其背后的微软借此狠狠向谷歌打了一波反击。至于这东西的实际功能，可能最有用的还是像楼下说的陪老人聊天。但是，老人们现在都分不清微信里传的谣言，还一天到晚转发。真搞成陪老人聊天的产品，就这错误百出却有说的头头是道的阿三风，迟早把大批老人都忽悠了。😁
家园 想到一个很实际的用途---陪老年人聊天，脾气好啊！ 家园 挑毛病很容易 但是没有意义
当前chatGPT的数据只更新到2021，所以一些新东西没有很正常。对不懂的东西胡说八道，其实也可以看做一种智能。
能用它来干点事，发现chatGPT有用的点，其实才是有价值的事
家园 试想一下，如果人人都用ChatGPT在西西河发帖 老铁会是怎样的心情？
我们这些喜爱西西河的河友们，又是怎样的心情？
很多人说，当我们遇到困扰时，ChatGPT会给我们一个现成的答案。我不知道，说这话的人，在打客服电话时，如果没有人工服务，会不会骂娘。
从区块链，比特币，元宇宙，再到ChatGPT，大洋对岸的人在虚拟世界的泡沫中出尽了风头，也离现实越来越远。
这实在是一件令人高兴的事情。
家园 这就是中文语料库太少训练的太差，该感谢互联网防火墙 无心插柳得让中国没沦为美国的数据农场
家园 也就是一个智能搜索引擎 前景不错，感觉目前对它的吹捧有点过了