西西河

主题:请教关于美国大萧条时间对老兵讨薪事件的镇压 -- krone

共:💬30 🌺21
分页树展主题 · 全看首页 上页
/ 2
下页 末页
        • 家园 原来有错误是不能批评的。

          受教。

            • -- 系统屏蔽 --。
            • 家园 太好了

              能批评就行。

              那么也不是只要批评美国,就得先批评TG以示“公平”吧?单独批评美国并不代表不批TG吧。

              俺们这是单批美国来了,TG一节,纵使该批,也不在今日的议程。

              “坦克轧人”说由来已久,无奈未见实证,未免稍微消减了小弟对TG的恨意。还望老兄给点影音提示,以助小弟重燃怒火。

                • 家园 NHK的片子我看过,Mike Wallace的访谈我看过

                  张良的"papers"也读过,没见到“坦克轧人”之说。

                  “装傻充愣”之类的话,从此不要再说。

                • 家园 支持

                  如果别人让我找什么,我就去找的话,我成了什么了?那么predictable很有面子吗?炒这个架有那么重要吗?

    • 家园 直接到《光荣与梦想》开头那儿找

      资料足够详细了,如果说不够客观冷静的话。

      参加镇压的有穿着整齐军装的麦克阿瑟,他的副官艾森豪威尔以及巴顿等名将。动用了6辆坦克,也开创了骑兵时代最后一次冲锋的记录。麦克阿瑟还违背胡佛总统的命令,扫荡了退伍军人驻地。有人死伤,包括婴儿,但应该没有现役军人。

      麦克阿瑟在完事之后没多久就到菲律宾去了,直到朝鲜战争打了败仗才回国。

    • 家园 记得当时是、麦克阿瑟镇压的
    • 家园 Need some research

      Sorry I cannot type Chinese now.

      I found a book on Amazon:

      The Bonus Army : An American Epic

      One of the readers wrote about this book:

      ..General Douglas MacArthur, years before he became famous in World War II, commanded a cavalry charge, one which involved his aide Major Dwight D. Eisenhower, and the saber-wielding Major George S. Patton, as well as tanks, machineguns, and teargas bombs. It was a charge in Washington DC in 1932, and it was against an enemy army of 20,000 US military veterans, and their families, and it was quite serious and even deadly. Patton urged his troops to use their bayonets: "If they resist, they must be killed." This was despite the presence among the veterans of a former soldier who had saved his life in World War I. The details of the charge, what lead up to it, and its eventual beneficial aftermath are told in _The Bonus Army: An American Epic_ (Walker Books) by Paul Dickson and Thomas B. Allen. The Bonus Army, while not unknown in American history books, is largely forgotten and is greatly misinterpreted as being part of the Red Scare of the time. There is fine research here and dramatic recollection of events that fully justify the book's subtitle. ...

      I don't own the book so cannot tell if it's useful to your question. But in general, such events could be buried in dust and the best way to dig out the truth is to look into some academic literature, like Jstor. Also, American universities' history courses can often provide vivid details.

      Years ago, I had a book about American military history, you may also find some details in those books.

      Good luck and let me know if you find the needed referece. And you can even write an article on that. As a rule, cchere encourages research and conscientious efforts to recover historical truth.

      关键词(Tags): #Bonus#Army
分页树展主题 · 全看首页 上页
/ 2
下页 末页


有趣有益,互惠互利;开阔视野,博采众长。
虚拟的网络,真实的人。天南地北客,相逢皆朋友

Copyright © cchere 西西河