西西河

主题:A国用国内法在B国抓了C国人。不是赤裸裸的霸权主义是什么 -- 友来有趣

共:💬90 🌺361 🌵8
全看分页树展 · 主题 跟帖
家园 这次怕是玩脱长臂管辖是一种超国土管辖的描述而并不必然有效

如果孟女士是欺诈的刑事案件,第一行为人在中国;第二所谓受害人是汇丰银行还是香港成立的,大股东是中国公司的,就算是英资银行吧;第三,涉嫌犯罪行为地在中国境内,大陆或香港。这里和美国,加拿大有任何联系吗?长臂管辖可不是国际法上必然成立的管辖权原则!第四,孟女士的行为在香港,在大陆,在交易发生地,是否构成了犯罪???是否因为该陈述造成了汇丰银行与伊朗发生了事实上的金融交易,这是否在中国和中国香港构成犯罪。

看看这个美国人讲的,美国在本案中根本就没有国际法上管辖的连接点:

有一个提出管辖权问题的美国评论,见下 新

Paul Wolf

18小时前

There is the presumption against extraterritorial application of US laws, and also the question of jurisdiction over her case. She is a Chinese citizen and anything that she did wrong, she did in China. The case has no contacts at all with the US. China should make its own extradition request, so that Ms. Wanzhou can be tried in a Chinese court. A Canadian judge considering two competing extradition requests would have to determine which country has a greater interest in the case.

Although its doubtful that violating US sanctions against Iran is a crime in China, she's also accused of making false statements on bank loan applications, which probably is. (fraud) Even if the case against her is weak, she will be badly mistreated and imprisoned for years until it's resolved. 出处在华盛顿邮报的文章下评论里。链接在我另一个帖子里。

全看分页树展 · 主题 跟帖


有趣有益,互惠互利;开阔视野,博采众长。
虚拟的网络,真实的人。天南地北客,相逢皆朋友

Copyright © cchere 西西河