西西河

主题:WG和八九 -- 本嘉明

共:💬175 🌺1405 🌵38
全看分页树展 · 主题 跟帖
家园 纪思道的那篇文章

我看过,即“CHINA UPDATE: HOW THE HARDLINERS WON”(By Nicholas D. Kristof,chief of The Times's Beijing bureau,Published: November 12, 1989;New York Times Sunday Week in Review)

该长文以人物介绍和日志形式,通过记述中共内部派系斗争,梳理8x8起源。涉及军车被劫一事,应该是以下部分:

JUNE 3. Thousands of troops have infiltrated into the capital, and people are growing accustomed to them - even in the Tiananmen Square area. The demonstration itself has lost much of its impetus, with many students from outside the capital returning to their homes. Fewer than 10,000 - probably considerably fewer - are still living in the square.

During the early hours of this Saturday morning, thousands of soldiers are sent into Beijing from the east, probably to bolster the show of force in the capital and gradually restore order. At this hour, the streets are empty of civilians, and it seems likely the plan was for the troops to enter the city quietly, without attracting attention.

But shortly before midnight, three miles west of Tiananmen, a speeding police van had swerved out of control, killing three bicyclists. An angry crowd quickly gathered, and many of the suspicious people insisted the incident was intentional. Some also declared that since the van was racing toward Tiananmen Square, the police must be preparing to evict the demonstrators.

The news has raced around Beijing, and, for the first time in a week, people swarm out of their houses to occupy the streets. The angry, defiant crowds soon encounter the exhausted soldiers, who are just finishing their forced march into the city, confirming the public impression that the authorities are scheming to attack the students. The indignant citizens search all vehicles passing by on the roads, and beat up some of the soldiers.

The troops are unarmed, probably to insure safety during the trip; their gear and weapons are transported separately in buses taking another route. Under normal conditions, these buses would never have been stopped, but after the accident, they are halted and searched, and machine guns are found. The discovery further inflames the crowds, and angry citizens confiscate the weapons.

JUNE 4. News that troops have been beaten, and guns stolen, alarms the conservative officials now holding the reins of power. Though the capital has been growing steadily calmer during the last week, the leaders decide they have to act decisively. And so Deng and his colleagues order the Army to take control of the city, using whatever force is required.

What happens before dawn on this Sunday has been much written about, and much confused. Based on my observations in the streets, neither the official account nor many of the foreign versions are quite correct.

There is no massacre in Tiananmen Square, for example, although there is plenty of killing elsewhere. Troops frequently fire at crowds who are no threat to them, and at times aim directly at medical personnel and ambulances. Some of those who are shot have been threatening the troops - for while the students have generally urged nonviolence, many young workers carry firebombs or pipes, and they manage to kill more than a dozen soldiers or policemen. But many other civilians are casually slaughtered for no apparent reason.

请注意,以上引文只提到运送武器的车辆被民众拦截,枪支被扣。并未有“暴徒获得枪支后,掉头向徒手的士兵扫射。。。。。。部队随后夺回枪支后,即开始破禁开枪”一说。

当时,路透社北京分社主任是Guy Dinmore。63夜,他在京西一带现场;而活动在天安门广场两侧的则是文字记者Andy Roche,Graham Earnshaw和Elizabeth Pisani(后两人本为路透社驻东京和雅加达记者,因懂汉语被急调至北京增援)。上述诸位事后的回忆都没有印证熊玠的说法。

全看分页树展 · 主题 跟帖


有趣有益,互惠互利;开阔视野,博采众长。
虚拟的网络,真实的人。天南地北客,相逢皆朋友

Copyright © cchere 西西河